Orders over $50+ Ship Free

Your Basket

📦 Spend another $48.99 and enjoy FREE Shipping

Congratulations! You have unlocked FREE Shipping!

Try these

Choco Hazel Spread 12oz

$12.99 $10.39

Add to Cart

Concord Grape Jelly 12oz

$12.99

Add to Cart

4 Ingredient Reese's Pumpkins

4 Ingredient Reese's Pumpkins

4 Ingredient Halloween Candy

 

Peanut butter pumpkins with a protein punch? Yes, please!

These easy-to-make Reese's pumpkins feature GOOD GOOD's Creamy Peanut Butter and Choco Hazel for a spooky good, sweet treat.

Ingredients:


Directions:
  1. In a small bowl, mix together GOOD GOOD Creamy Peanut Butter, maple syrup and protein powder. Combine until a dough forms.
  2. Flatten peanut butter dough onto parchment paper
  3. Using a pumpkin shaped cookie cutter, make as many peanut butter pumpkins as you can
  4. Place the pumpkins in freezer for an hour to harden
  5. Melt GOOD GOOD Choco Hazel in the microwave for 1-2 minutes at 50% power
  6. Dip peanut butter pumpkins into melted Choco Hazel
  7. Place in freezer for at least an hour & enjoy!

Good Good Brand Logo

ABOUT GOOD GOOD BRAND

Born in Reykjavik, Iceland and made in the EU, GOOD GOOD is sweetening up pantries worldwide with no added sugar. Our team has grown to our new office space in Austin, Texas, where we continue to bring better-for-you spreads to every kind of eater – from health-conscious shoppers to flavor seekers who just want to cut back on sugar.

Made with real, non-GMO ingredients, our jams, jellies, and spreads deliver the nostalgic flavors you love without compromise. Whether you're starting your day, upgrading your snacks, or treating yourself, GOOD GOOD makes life's little moments sweeter.

LEARN MORE

People also read

  1. Viral Strawberry Dot Cake Recipe (No Added Sugar)
  2. 10 Delicious Ways to Use No Added Sugar Raspberry Jam
  3. Giant Love Letter Puff Pastry
  4. Protein PB&J Crispy Rice Treats
  5. No-Bake Chocolate Peanut Butter Crunch Cups

Popular recipes

Viral Strawberry Dot Cake Recipe (No Added Sugar)

Viral Strawberry Dot Cake Recipe (No Added Sugar)

8th June 2026
10 Delicious Ways to Use No Added Sugar Raspberry Jam

10 Delicious Ways to Use No Added Sugar Raspberry Jam

21st May 2026
Giant Love Letter Puff Pastry

Giant Love Letter Puff Pastry

17th May 2026
Protein PB&J Crispy Rice Treats

Protein PB&J Crispy Rice Treats

17th May 2026